Showing posts with label unconscionable. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unconscionable. Show all posts

Monday, March 28, 2016

California Supreme Court Upholds Arbitration Agreement Against Unconscionability Claim

Baltazar v. Forever 21, Inc. is one of the older employment cases on the California Supreme Court's docket. It has now been put to rest. And the employer came out the winner via a unanimous Court.  Justice Kruger wrote the opinion.

This is another arbitration case, focusing on whether an employer's agreement to arbitrate was "unconscionable" because it included certain provisions.  First, the Court does a nice job of summarizing its recent arbitration cases so that practitioners can one-stop shop  for case law. Thank you Supreme Court. 

When evaluating arbitration agreements, the courts look for procedural and substantive unconscionability. The more procedural unconsionability they find, the less substantive unconscionability they need to discern.  And vice versa.  They call this the "sliding scale."

Procedural Unconscionability

So, the first piece of business the Court addressed is the issue of "procedural unconscionability." That is, whether the arbitration agreement was "take it or leave it" and whether it was obtained via trick or surprise.

Now, as a practical matter, nearly every employment arbitration agreement has some degree of "procedural" unconscionability, because they are almost always "take it or leave it," or "contracts of adhesion."  And here's where the court explained that it will not count an "adhesion" contract as a significant amount of procedural unconscionability unless there is something more - evidence that the employer hid the agreement, or lied to the employee.   

In this case, Baltazar knew about the agreement And she even tried to refuse to sign it.  The employer told her if she did not sign, she would have no job.  The agreement was presented to her in a straight-forward way. Therefore, the court said it was a plain-old adhesion contract. 

The Court also addressed the argument that the employer did not attache the AAA rules to the arbitration contract as evidence of procedural unconscionability. The Court said that there was nothing Baltazar pointed to in the rules that affected her rights. Therefore, there was nothing in the rules that created more procedural unconscionability because they were not given to her.  

Substantive Unconscionability

The Court then turned to Baltazar's substantive unconscionability arguments.  Her first argument was that the arbitration agreement stated that either party could seek injunctive relief in accordance with the California Civil Procedure Code's section 1281.8.   Yes, she argued that the agreement was illegal because it included a statute's provision within it.   Bad argument?  Not when you consider that a previous court of appeal (Trivedi v. Curexo Technology Corp. (2010) 189 Cal.App.4th 387) had held just that.  The court in Trivedi held that a provision that simply stated that either party could seek injunctive relief was unconscionable because employers were more likely to use it.   Goodbye Trivedi.  The Supreme Court disapproved it.  It was on the books for 6 years too long.  


Baltazar also argued that the list of covered claims in the arbitration agreement was unconscionable because only employee-type claims were specifically mentioned.  Here's what the agreement said, as described by the Court:
The parties “mutually agree” to arbitrate “any claim or action arising out of or in any way related to the hire, employment, remuneration, separation or termination of Employee.” The agreement specifies that the disputes subject to arbitration “include but are not limited to: claims for wages or other compensation due; claims for breach of any employment contract or covenant (express or implied); claims for unlawful discrimination, retaliation or harassment . . . , and Disputes arising out of or relating to the termination of the employment relationship between the parties, whether based on common law or statute, regulation, or ordinance.”
The Court had no trouble finding that this language included all claims whether brought by the employer or employee:
The illustrative list of claims subject to the agreement is just that; the agreement specifically states that such claims “include but are not limited to” the enumerated claims, thus making clear that the list is not intended to be exhaustive. It thus casts no doubt on the comprehensive reach of the arbitration agreement. It is not particularly remarkable that the agreement’s list of examples might highlight certain types of claims that employees often bring, since part of the purpose of the agreement is to put employees such as Baltazar on notice regarding the scope of the agreement, thus eliminating any possible surprise.
Finally, Baltazar tried to argue that the agreement's provision protecting trade secrets and confidential information rendered the agreement unconscionable.  Again, the Court was not having it.

Baltazar argues that the arbitration agreement here is unduly one-sided because it provides that, in the course of arbitration, “all necessary steps will be taken to protect from public disclosure [Forever 21’s] trade secrets and proprietary and confidential information.” Baltazar contends that because the agreement neither defines “all necessary steps” nor specifies what constitutes “proprietary and confidential information,” the agreement unfairly demands that employees take whatever steps the employer deems “necessary” to protect whatever information the employer claims to be “proprietary and confidential.”
Baltazar misreads the confidentiality provision. Nothing in the agreement indicates that an employee must accede to any and all demands Forever 21 might make for the protection of confidential and proprietary information. As defendants explain: “This provision contemplates that if trade secret, confidential and proprietary information need[s] to be introduced into the arbitration that the parties [will] work with the arbitrator to make sure that such information is not disclosed to the public.” The agreement does not restrict the use of such information in the proceeding, nor does it pretermit any determination of whether a particular piece of information is a trade secret or otherwise qualifies as proprietary and confidential. Agreements to protect sensitive information are a regular feature of modern litigation, and they carry with them no inherent unfairness.
To the extent that Baltazar’s complaint is instead that the agreement calls for the protection of an employer’s confidential information without similarly calling for the protection of the confidential information of employees, we disagree with the suggestion that this omission renders the arbitration agreement unduly harsh or one-sided. As we stated in Armendariz, supra, 24 Cal.4th at page 117: “ ‘[A] contract can provide a “margin of safety” that provides the party with superior bargaining strength a type of extra protection for which it has a legitimate commercial need without being unconscionable. [Citation.]’ ” Here, the basis for the extra measure of protection is a legitimate commercial need to protect Forever 21’s “valuable trade secrets and proprietary and confidential information” from public disclosure. Although Baltazar may dislike the wording of the confidentiality provision, she does not dispute that it is based on a legitimate commercial need. Moreover, nothing in the agreement precludes employees from seeking comparable protection for their personal information during arbitration proceedings, as circumstances may warrant.
So, this case is another one that will make it easier to draft arbitration agreements without worrying about excessive false mutuality.   You know what I mean.

This case is Baltazar v. Forever 21, Inc. and the opinion is here. 

Monday, December 14, 2015

U.S. Supremes Enforce Arbitration Agreement, Reversing California Appellate Court

The U.S. Supreme Court in Direct TV Inc. v. Imburgia (opinion here) took on the California Court of Appeal in a test of the Federal Arbitration Act's preemptive force. Guess who won?

This case involves Direct TV's attempt to include a class-action waiver in an arbitration agreement as part of its service contract with customers.  Before the U.S. Supreme Court in AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 563 U. S. 333 (2011), ruled that such waivers were valid under the Federal Arbitration Act, state courts (like California's) could invalidate class actions waivers as "unconscionable" or invalid against public policy. See Discover Bank v. Superior Court, 36 Cal. 4th 148 (2005).

So, Direct TV inserted a provision in its arbitration agreement that hedged against the possibility of invalidation by a state court, as explained by the Supreme Court in its opinion:
if the “law of your state” makes the waiver of class arbitration unenforceable, then the entire arbitration provision “is unenforceable.” Id., at 129. Section 10 of the contract states that §9, the arbitration provision, “shall be governed by the Federal Arbitration Act.”
This way, if California held that a class waiver is invalid, the whole case (class action and all) would be heard in court. 

Then, of course, the U.S. Supreme Court decided a case that preempted California law invalidating class-action waivers.  Even the California Supreme Court had to agree that if the Federal Arbitration Act applies, class action waivers in arbitration agreements are OK.  Therefore, one might say, the "law of the state" about class-waivers was gone.  What happened to this clause then? Well that's what this case is about.

The Court of Appeal interpreted the above language to say that the "state law" would continue to apply without regard to federal preemption.  That is, the "law of your state" would continue to prohibit class action waivers under this agreement, despite the preemption of the law by the Supreme Court.  And, despite the arbitration agreement's specific provision that the Federal Arbitration Act applies. 

6-3, the Supreme Court rejected the Court of Appeal's decision.  The Court decided that for the Court of Appeal to be correct, the term "law of your state" had to include "invalid" state law.  The Court then decided that the Court of Appeal would never have interpreted the term "law of your state" to include "invalid" state law unless this contract were an arbitration agreement. Therefore, because the Court of Appeal disfavored arbitration agreements, its decision violated the Federal Arbitration Act. 

nothing in the Court of Appeal’s reasoning suggests that a California court would reach the same interpretation of “law of your state” in any context other than arbitration. The Court of Appeal did not explain why parties might generally intend the words “law of your state” to encompass “invalid law of your state.” To the contrary, the contract refers to “state law” that makes the waiver of class arbitration “unenforceable,” while an in- valid state law would not make a contractual provision unenforceable. Assuming—as we must—that the court’s reasoning is a correct statement as to the meaning of “law of your state” in this arbitration provision, we can find nothing in that opinion (nor in any other California case) suggesting that California would generally interpret words such as “law of your state” to include state laws held invalid because they conflict with, say, federal labor statutes, federal pension statutes, federal antidiscrimination laws, the Equal Protection Clause, or the like. 
And as for disfavoring arbitration:

The view that state law retains independent force even after it has been authoritatively invalidated by this Court is one courts are unlikely to accept as a general matter and to apply in other contexts.
Justice Thomas believes the Federal Arbitration Act does not preempt any case brought in state court and would have affirmed the court of appeal. So he dissented on that special ground. 

Justices Ginsburg (writing) joined by Justice Sotomayor dissented on the merits, arguing that  Direct TV should be held to its original intent: to enforce the agreement only if state law (without regard to federal preemption) would allow the class waiver. The agreement was written before the Supreme Court ruled class action waivers were allowed and state laws to the contrary were preempted; therefore, the agreement's intent was not to include federal law in the mix.  

So, another anti-arbitration case goes by the wayside. But California's anti-arbitration case law remains on the books and strong because Armendariz and its progeny are still in force.  Therefore, it remains important to draft arbitration agreements in employment settings carefully. 




Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Ninth Circuit Upholds Dispute Resolution Policy in Handbook As Enforceable Arbitration Agreement

Especially in California, an arbitration agreement practically has to be written in pencil. Getting an arbitration agreement to conform with all the new court decisions feels like nailing jello to a wall. Herding cats.  Hitting a moving target.  You get the picture.

So, from an administrative standpoint, it's much easier to have an arbitration agreement that can be amended from time to time and simply distributed via handbook revision, along with an acknowledgment of receipt.  There are limits on doing so, such as adequate notice of a change and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing that would apply to any contract. 

But some may question whether a policy in a handbook is an enforceable "agreement" to arbitrate at all.  The Ninth Circuit thought so in Ashbey v. Archstone Prop. Mgmt.  Opinion here.

Ashbey signed the following acknowledgement (at least twice) during his employment.
I acknowledge that I have received directions as to how I may access the Archstone Company Policy Manual, including the Dispute Resolution Policy. I understand that Archstone can administer, interpret, discontinue, supplement, amend or withdraw any of the employment and personnel policies and procedures set forth in this Company Policy Manual. I understand that it is my responsibility to understand the Archstone Company Policy Manual, including the Dispute Resolution Policy, and to adhere to all of the policies contained herein.
The Dispute Resolution Policy stated:
This Policy is governed by the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq. . . . Except as it otherwise provides, this Policy is intended to apply to the resolution of disputes that otherwise would be resolved in a court of law, and therefore this Policy requires all such disputes between Employee and the Company to be resolved only by an arbitrator through final and binding arbitration and not by way of court or jury trial. . . . This Policy also applies, without limitation, to disputes arising out of the employment relationship or the termination thereof including, without limitation, disputes over . . . harassment and claims arising under the . . . Civil Rights Act of 1964 . . . and all other state statutory and common law claims. 
Ashley argued that the acknowledgment and policy were ineffective to waive his right to a jury trial on his federal Title VII claim and analogous state law claim for discrimination. He claimed that his waiver was not knowing and voluntary because the receipt did not contain the Dispute Resolution policy. The court of appeals disagreed:
the Acknowledgment here explicitly notified Ashbey the Manual contained a Dispute Resolution Policy, and it did so in two places. And Ashbey expressly agreed “to adhere” to the Manual and the Dispute Resolution Policy. That the Acknowledgment did not list the terms of the Policy is not fatal to the Policy’s enforcement. The full text of the Policy was at Ashbey’s fingertips; he acknowledged he had received directions on how to access both the Manual and the Dispute Resolution Policy contained in the Manual. Anyone who reviewed the Dispute Resolution Policy would immediately realize he was “entering into an agreement to waive a specific statutory remedy afforded him by a civil rights statute.” Nelson, 119 F.3d at 762. The Dispute Resolution Policy was not ambiguous on that point: (1) the policy stated it “is governed by the Federal Arbitration Act”; (2) the policy stated that “all . . . disputes between Employee and the Company [are] to be resolved only by an arbitrator through final and binding arbitration and not by way of court or jury trial”; and (3) the policy stated it “applies, without limitation, to disputes arising out of the employment relationship . . . including, without limitation, disputes over . . . harassment and claims arising under the . . . Civil Rights Act of 1964.”
So, the Court held that the policy was knowing and voluntary.  

In a companion, unpublished decision, the court also held that the policy contained in the handbook was enforceable as an agreement under California unconscionability law.  The court noted that policies can be enforceable as contracts, even when incorporated into the signed acknowledgment.  The court also found that the attorney's fees and other provisions were satisfactory. 
The analysis relies on California opinions and is useful for crafting these types of arbitration agreements. So, although unpublished, it will be useful.  That unpublished opinion is here. 





Friday, May 16, 2014

Court of Appeal: Arbitrator Can Decide Unconscionability

Here's a case that could favor employment arbitration in California.  If it stays on the books.  The Court of Appeal held that an arbitration agreement lawfully delegated to the arbitrator the responsibility to determine if the arbitration agreement was enforceable.  That is, the arbitrator, not the court, would decide if the agreement is unconscionable.

In a nutshell, as stated by the Court:

Several years after she was hired, Lourdes Tiri signed an agreement with her employer, Lucky Chances, Inc., requiring disputes between them to be resolved by arbitration. In one of the provisions, the parties agreed to delegate questions about the enforceability of the agreement to the arbitrator, instead of a court. Tiri was subsequently fired, and she filed a complaint in superior court for wrongful discharge. Lucky Chances petitioned to compel arbitration, but the trial court denied the petition on the basis that the arbitration agreement was unconscionable and therefore unenforceable.

Lucky Chances appeals the court’s order denying arbitration. We hold that the trial court lacked the authority to rule on the enforceability of the agreement because the parties’ delegation of this authority to the arbitrator was clear and is not revocable under state law. Accordingly, we reverse.

What-what-what?  Read on.

The arbitration agreement contained this language:

The agreement also includes an explicit provision that delegates to the arbitrator issues regarding the agreement’s enforceability: “The Arbitrator, and not any federal, state, or local court or agency, shall have the exclusive authority to resolve any dispute relating to the interpretation, applicability, enforceability, or formation of this Agreement, including, but not limited to, any claim that all or any part of this Agreement is void or voidable.” 
As the court noted, that is a delegation clause, which grants the arbitrator the jurisdiction to determine  whether the arbitration agreement is enforceable.  In the absence of that sort of clause, a court determines whether there is a valid agreement, including whether the agreement is "unconscionable."
As you know if you're reading this, in California, there is a lot of litigation in court over that issue.

Here's why the delegation clause is important. The trial court denied the employer's motion to compel arbitration?  Why?  1) the agreement was "take it or leave it," i.e., procedurally unconscionable and 2) the employer did not attach the AAA arbitration rules, even though it cited the website where they must be found.  Those two facts rendered the agreement "unconscionable," a word that has been stretched into meaninglessness.  It used to mean something like "so one-sided as to shock the judicial consciousness," but now it simply means "not exactly perfect."

The court of appeal made some important rulings. First, the court recognized its decision would be the same under California's or the federal arbitration acts.  Second, the court explained that the court may consider challenges to the delegation clause itself, but not to the enforceability of the agreement to arbitrate as a whole.

Third, the court explained that a delegation clause is enforceable if (1) it is clear and unmistakable (2) if the clause itself is not void because of some defense applicable to any contract (fraud, duress, unconscionability).

The court found the language above was clear and unmistakable.  The employee argued that the clause was unconscionable.  The court of appeal found it was procedurally unconscionable (because it was "take it or leave it.").  But the court also found no reason that a delegation clause automatically is substantively unconscionable.  And there was nothing about this delegation clause that rendered it one-sided or non-mutual. Therefore, it was not unconscionable as a whole.

Of course, the arbitrator is free to rule on whether the agreement as a whole is unconscionable. So, there may still be litigation over such agreements. But they will be in arbitration.  If this ruling stands, it will certainly make arbitration agreements easier to enforce without court litigation.

This case is Tiri v. Lucky Chances, Inc. and the opinion is here.