Sunday, July 22, 2007

Final California AB1825 Sexual Harassment Training Regulations (Really)

The Fair Employment and Housing Commission reports here that the California Office of Administrative Law has approved the final AB 1825 sexual harassment training regulations.
Here are the regulations.

They will become effective on or about August 17. Employers have until then to ensure that their training programs are in compliance with the specifics. There are provisions that may require employers' attention. Here are a few:

1. Electronic learning -
An employer utilizing a webinar for its supervisors must document and demonstrate that each supervisor who was not physically present in the same room as the trainer nonetheless attended the entire training and actively participated with the training’s interactive content, discussion questions, hypothetical scenarios, quizzes or tests, and activities. The webinar must provide the supervisors an opportunity to ask questions, to have them answered and otherwise to seek guidance and assistance.
2. Who are qualified trainers -

(A) A trainer shall be one or more of the following:
1. "Attorneys" admitted for two or more years to the bar of any state in the United States and whose practice includes employment law under the Fair Employment and Housing Act and/or Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, or
2. "Human resource professionals" or "harassment prevention consultants" working as employees or independent contractors with a minimum of two or more years of
practical experience in one or more of the following: a. designing or conducting
discrimination, retaliation and sexual harassment prevention training; b. responding to sexual harassment complaints or other discrimination complaints; c. conducting investigations of sexual harassment complaints; or d. advising employers or employees regarding discrimination, retaliation and sexual harassment prevention, or
3. "Professors or instructors" in law schools, colleges or universities who have a post-graduate degree or California teaching credential and either 20 instruction hours or two or more years of experience in a law school, college or university teaching about employment law under the Fair Employment and Housing Act and/or Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964.

(B) Individuals who do not meet the qualifications of a trainer as an attorney, human resource professional, harassment prevention consultant, professor or instructor because they lack the requisite years of experience may team teach with a trainer in classroom or webinar trainings provided that the trainer supervises these individuals and the trainer is available throughout the training to answer questions from training attendees.

Documentation -

(2) Documentation of Training. An employer shall keep documentation of the training provided its employees under this section to track compliance, including the name supervisory employee trained, the date of training, the type of training, and the name the training provider and shall retain the records for a minimum of two years.
Small employers crossing the 50 employee threshold - six months to do the training

Content - review your training programs carefully to ensure all the elements care covered.

Too much trouble? Well, I have a suggestion [shameless plug alert!]:

http://shawvalenza.com/about_training.php

DGV

9th Circuit Sets Low Bar on Employer Liability for Employees' Conduct

Poland was with the Customs Service in Denver. Hillberry was his supervisor. Hillberry demonstrated some anti-age animus towards Poland. Poland at some point filed a charge of discrimination. Later, Hillberry requested an administrative review of Poland's management of subordinates. The reviewers found that Poland engaged in unprofessional conduct as a manager. As a result, Poland was demoted to a non-supervisory job and transferred to Vienna Virginia.
Poland accepted the transfer, but retired 3 years before the mandatory retirement age.

Poland sued for, among other things, retaliation and constructive discharge. He said that the administrative review was retaliation for his age discrimination claim. The trial court awarded damages for constructive discharge and retaliation.

The Ninth Circuit reversed on the constructive discharge claim. 2/3 of the judges said that Poland did not establish his working conditions were intolerable merely because he was demoted and transferred. Among other things, the court noted that Poland worked 5 months in Virginia, contradicting his argument the transfer created intolerable conditions.

The really significant part of the case, though, is the Ninth Circuit's stance on liability for actions taken by innocent superiors on the basis of lower level employees' complaints. Hillberry did instigate the investigation into Poland's conduct, true. But the court did not rely on that alone and said that Hillberry's referral alone would not have been enough. Rather, the court focused on the fact that the investigators had access to Hillberry's notes, that Hillberry gave the list of witnesses to the investigators, and that the panel relied on performance reviews that had increased in frequency after Poland filed his first discrimination complaint.

In upholding Poland's claim, the court announced the rule for holding employers liable for negative, non-discriminatory actions taken on the basis of an employee's complaint that is tainted by bias:

We hold that if a subordinate, in response to a plaintiff’s protected activity, sets in motion a proceeding by an independent decisionmaker that leads to an adverse employment action, the subordinate’s bias is imputed to the employer if the plaintiff can prove that the allegedly independent adverse employment decision was not actually independent because the biased subordinate influenced or was involved in the decision or decisionmaking process.

The court added that if the investigation is "entirely independent" of the subordinate's influence, the animus of the retaliating employee is not imputed to the employer.

So, if an employee engages in protected activity by complaining against a manager, that manager cannot be the impetus for negative treatment against the complaining employee, unless an "entirely independent" investigation finds the negative treatment is justified. Otherwise, the odds of a retaliation finding are very high.

The case is Poland v. Chertoff. Opinion is here.

Friday, July 20, 2007

EEOC Revises Age Discrimination Regulations

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has revised its regulations regarding enforcement of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. The text of the affected regulations as revised is here. The purpose of the revisions is to conform them with the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in General Dynamics Land System, Inc. v. Cline, 540 U.S. 581 (2004). There, the Supreme Court held that the ADEA prohibits only age discrimination against employees that are older than there comparators. That means that an employee over 40 cannot complain that an older employee was favored over him or her, even though the over-40 employee is covered by ADEA.
The new text of the regulation makes clear:
Favoring an older individual over a younger individual because of age is not unlawful discrimination under the ADEA, even if the younger individual is at least 40 years old. However, the ADEA does not require employers to prefer older individuals and does not affect applicable state, municipal, or local laws that prohibit such preferences.

More Employment Law Articles

Wondering what to read at the beach this summer? Well, we've been busy writing articles.
Here are links to some of the recent ones. Wear sunscreen in case you fall asleep.

WORKPLACE BULLYING AND THE FUTURE OF THE “EQUAL OPPORTUNITY HARASSER” By Jennifer Brown Shaw and Becki Graham

ENFORCING NON-COMPETE AGREEMENTS IN CALIFORNIA AFTER ADVANCED BIONICS V. MEDTRONIC
By D. Gregory Valenza

INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS: A DYING BREED?
By D. Gregory Valenza

FREE SPEECH AND ENGLISH-ONLY POLICIES IN THE WORKPLACE
By Jennifer Brown Shaw and Matthew J. Norfleet

DGV

U.S. Supreme Court Roundup 2006-2007

Here is our article summarizing the Supreme Court's labor and employment law decisions during the 2006 Term. We also note the three pending cases that will be addressed next Term, beginning in October 2007.

Greg

Monday, July 16, 2007

California Supreme Court: CEO's Malicious Prosecution Action OK

Sometimes plaintiffs and their lawyers like to sue the CEO or another high level executive for what they call "in terrorem" effect. You know, it's an attention getter. Other times individual defendants are added to defeat the possibility of federal court jurisdiction.

They say, though, if you go for the king, make sure you kill him. Because if you don't, he has the resources to sue you all the way to the Supreme Court.

Thomas Siebel is one such CEO. Debra Christoffers sued him and Siebel Systems for a variety of claims, many of which may not be asserted against individual managers as a matter of settled law. After Mr. Siebel won on the claims asserted against him as an individual, he sued Christoffers' attorneys, E. Rick Buell II and Carol L. Mittlesteadt for malicious prosecution. The trial court threw the case out. The court of appeal reinstated Siebel's case.

The complication here was that all parties settled Christoffers' underlying lawsuit and the cross-actions while that suit was on appeal. Mittlesteadt therefore argued that Mr. Siebel could not sue for malicious prosecution because he did not receive a "favorable" judgment in the underlying case.

The Supreme Court, 7-0, decided Mr. Siebel was free to proceed on his malicious prosecution claim even though the parties settled the underlying lawsuit. The opinion is here. The case is Siebel v. Mittlesteadt.

Those plaintiff attorneys who sue individual defendants based on frivolous legal theories may take away something from this decision. To be honest, in my experience, most plaintiffs' lawyers are more professional than that.

Greg

Thursday, July 05, 2007

New (Federal) Minimum Wage Poster

New federal minimum wage? New federal minimum wage poster! And it's a beauty. Here.
Your current FLSA minimum wage poster is good through July 24, 2007.

DGV

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

Court of Appeal Protects Investigator During Litigation

Bessie Gallanis-Politis sued her employer, LA County, for discrimination. During the litigation, a couple of supervisors investigated certain issues, purportedly to help prepare the discovery responses. They also took a number of other, incidental, actions, including requiring Gallanis-Politis to change her attendance records to "unapproved absence" when she attended depositions. She amended her complaint, suing the individual supervisors for retaliation. The Court of Appeal held that the supervisors' conduct arose from the litigation and were protected by California's anti-SLAPP law. In other words, the court said that Gallanis-Politis retaliated against the supervisors in violation of the statute. This case protects employees from employee-plaintiffs who attempt to sue managers involved in the defense of the case, and employee-plaintiffs who attempt to shield themselves from neutral policies during litigation. The case is Gallanis-Politis v. Medina, and the opinion is here.

Court of Appeal Upholds Termination for Personal Work on Company Time

Loggins v. Kaiser Permanente upholds summary judgment against an employee's claim of race discrimination and retaliation. Loggins was fired because over 80% of her hard drive contained personal documents. She was accused of devoting too much work time to personal business. (Bloggers and Internet junkies, beware). The case is important because it holds (1) timing of adverse action alone is not sufficient to prove pretext when alleging retaliation (2) the standard for retaliation claims under the Fair Employment and Housing Act is the same as under common law (wrongful termination) and (3) the employer's legitimate business reason simply must be "legitimate" -- non-discriminatory -- and is not held to any additional scrutiny for "fairness" or accuracy.

Damages in California Employment Law Cases

The court of appeal in Davis v. Los Angeles Unified School District Personnel Commission explains a number of principles applicable to damages awards in employment law cases. The case involves an employee who successfully claimed he was wrongfully demoted. The appeal concerns the measure of damages. The court held :the plaintiff does not recover back pay during the period when he or she is unable to work due to a non-industrial disability. The court also said that the employee is not entitled to reinstatement until he can perform the functions of the job. The court also explains how back pay is calculated with respect to mitigation. The opinion covers the "mixed motive" defense's effect on damages. This is a key case for settlement discussions, mediations, and if those fail - jury instructions on damages.

DGV

IRS May Tax Emotional Distress Damages

Last year, the D.C. Circuit held that emotional distress damages were not taxable and that to do so was unconstitutional. The case, Murphy v. IRS, arose in the context of an employment law matter. Well, the same panel just reversed itself. The court held that emotional distress damages not arising from physical injury were properly taxed under the Internal Revenue Code. Here is the opinion. Don't read it unless you enjoy the tax code, constitutional law, or want to turn to stone. Just saying.

DGV

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

U.S. Department of Labor FMLA Analysis

The U.S. DOL sought comments on its FMLA regulations last fall and winter. They have come out with a thorough report. It's so thorough, the executive summary alone is 12 pages. Originally, they were seeking these comments in contemplation of possible revisions. But the report does not mention what if any revisions are under consideration. For now, you may wish to read the report to confirm what you already know: intermittent leave and medical certification are the most difficult parts of FMLA to administer. Most employers are fine with bona fide leave for birth and adoption and for truly serious health conditions. See? It took me only two lines to give you this blinding glimpse of the obvious.

Tuesday, June 26, 2007

Court of Appeal Upholds Summary Judgment Against Disability Discrimination Claim

UPS has very strict policies enforcing the U.S. Department of Transportation's hours of work standards. King was a supervisor, responsible for ensuring employees logged hours properly, and managing the employees so they did not exceed DOT guidelines. After several warnings, King apparently persuaded an employee to revise a time card so it would appear she was not in violation of the DOT standard. After an investigation, UPS fired King. He had over 30 years of service. UPS thought highly of him. But they found his conduct to be an integrity violation and discharged him.
King sued for disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable accommodation, and breach of contract. The court of appeal in a strongly worded opinion, King v. UPS, held that King failed to raise a triable issue of fact. King did not deny what he did. The court swept aside King's efforts to argue that he had just returned from a medical leave of absence, that the employee with the false time card was not really at risk of going over hours, and that his managers conspired against him because he did not introduce evidence that UPS's stated reason for firing him - King's conduct - was untrue and was instead a mask for discrimination. The court detailed the summary judgment standard in discrimination cases, synthesizing a number of principles developed over time. The court's main point is that if the employer has a good faith belief that a manager engaged in misconduct, the plaintiff must do more than speculate about hidden reasons.

DGV

Monday, June 25, 2007

"No-Hire" Agreement Is Unenforceable in California

Consultant firms often assign consultants to work closely with clients. Sometimes consultant companies include "no hire" agreements, under which the customer is precluded from hiring consultant's employees for a period of time. In VL Systems, Inc. v. Unisen, Inc., the court of appeal held that such a no-hire agreement was unenforceable in California as an illegal non-compete. The court left open the possibility that a more narrow agreement might be enforceable. However, the fact that the consultant company's agreement made it illegal to hire any of the consultant's employees - even ones never assigned to work for the customer - rendered the agreement overly broad and unenforceable.

DGV

Monday, June 18, 2007

Happy Birthday to Shaw Valenza LLP!

We started our Firm a year ago today, on June 19, 2006. We are proud of what we have accomplished during our first year. And we look forward to more self-congratulatory posts in the years to come!

Thank you for reading the blog over the past year. We posted about 90 items. We tried to catch everything, but probably fell short. So let's say we tried to catch the important developments. We hope we have succeeded in becoming a valuable resource for our readers.

Best wishes,

Greg

Thursday, June 14, 2007

California Administrative Exemption Inapplicable

Eicher v. ABI contains a thorough analysis of the administrative exemption to overtime law.

Here are the facts from the opinion:
ABI owns the rights to ABI MasterMind software . . . ABI’s primary business is
to sell the software . . . , implement the software for the customer, train the
customer, and provide additional support. During the implementation phase, ABI typically sends its employees to the customer’s site to install and train the customer, based on the specific needs of that customer. . . . Hired as a consultant, Eicher eventually became a senior consultant. His college degree was in sociology, not computer science. He spent half of his time in the office and the other half on-site
at customers’ venues. Eicher primarily provided customer service and training on the ABI MasterMind software. He did not hire or fire employees, negotiate contracts with customers, or consult with ABI or its customers about business policies and practices. . . . Concerning Eicher’s duties as an employee of ABI, the trial court found that Eicher “devoted the majority of his work time in training customer employees on MasterMind and troubleshooting the software when he was engaged in implementation on the customer’s site. [Eicher] also spent time gathering information about the customers’ employment practices and entering data into the appropriate fields of the MasterMind program. [Eicher] testified that he spent the
majority of his time, when in [ABI’s] office, performing customer service work. The remainder of his time was spent on individual training and administrative duties.
So, Eicher was exempt, right? Wrong. The court noted that he was a "production" employee, involved in implementing ABI's core business. He did not affect policy at the customer or his employer. He simply customized the ABI software for the customer's use.

The court did not entertain ABI's argument that Eicher qualified under the administrative exemption because he “carr[ies] out major assignments in conducting the operations of the business, or whose work affects business operations to a substantial degree.” ABI did not make that argument at the trial court and did not support it with evidence, the court of appeal said.

The moral: The administrative exemption is not a catch all for all office-based work. Also, if the employee is generating revenue for the business, chances are the administrative exemption will not apply. Where does this decision leave lower level consultants assigned to work on customers' projects? (Watch your backs consultant firms. There be sharks in these waters).

DGV

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Article: Sexual Harassment Training Not a How-to-Sue

Professor Caren Goldberg of American University concluded a study of 234 white-collar professionals in which she concludes sexual harassment training does not encourage employees to file lawsuits. The study's findings are reported in this article, published in the Insurance Journal on June 7. In California and Connecticut, training is the law anyway. But we have always believed the benefits of anti-harassment training outweigh the potential risks. This study backs up that conclusion.

DGV

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Federal Minimum Wage Increase Approved

California's minimum wage is higher than the federal counterpart. But California employers with operations in other states may be interested to know the federal minimum wage is going up. Part of an Iraq funding bill, HR 2206, the minimum wage increase to $5.85 per hour (from $5.15) takes effect 60 days from May 25, the date of its passage. 12 months later, the wage increases to $6.55, and then to $7.25 12 months after that. The text of the new federal minimum wage law is here.

The California minimum wage presently is $7.50 and will rise to $8.00 on January 1, 2008.

San Francisco's minimum wage for 2007 is $9.16 and changes (increases) every year because it is indexed to inflation.

DGV

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

U.S. Supreme Court Clarifies Title VII Statute of Limitations

Lilly Ledbetter claimed Goodyear discriminated against her based on her sex by setting her pay lower than male counterparts. As a result, her pay continued to be lower over time. Years after the allegedly discriminatory pay decisions, she brought a claim of sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VII requires plaintiffs to file administrative charges within 180 days of the discriminatory decision. But Ledbetter argued that each paycheck was a new discriminatory decision to pay her, based on the initial discriminatory setting of her pay.

The Supreme Court held (5-4) that the EEOC charge was untimely. Reviewing its prior decisions on the issue, the Court held: "The EEOC charging period is triggered when a discrete unlawful practice takes place. A new violation does not occur, and a new charging period does not commence, upon the occurrence of subsequent nondiscriminatory acts that entail adverse effects resulting from the past discrimination. But of course, if an employer engages in a series of acts each of which is intentionally discriminatory, then a fresh violation takes place when each act is committed."

Thus, the "continuing violation" doctrine has no applicability to pay cases where the initial decision resulted in lower pay, but there were no later, discriminatory decisions perpetuating the initial wrong.

The case is Ledbetter v. Goodyear.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Law Firm's Arbitration Agreement Unenforceable

O'Melveny & Myers is a giant and well respected law firm. Its arbitration agreement received no respect from the Ninth Circuit, though. Applying California law, the Ninth Circuit held the agreement failed the test for unconscionability:

- It was a take-it-or-leave-it agreement, even though it was announced three months before its effective date. An "opt out" is not procedurally unconscionable only if it permits "opting out" of the arbitration clause, not opting out of the employment relationship.

- The agreement barred all claims not asserted within a year of their occurrence. The court of appeals held that the shortened statute of limitations was unconscionable. The court distinguished a case where a shortened statute of limitations was held to be lawful - the lawful limitations period was measured as six months from the employee's termination, rather than from when the claim was discovered.

- The agreement contained a broad confidentiality clause, prohibiting disclosure that there was a claim or an arbitration. The court said this was unconscionable because it precluded employees from discovering "repeat players" before the same arbitrators, as well as "precedent" in applying the arbitration agreement.

- The agreement contained a "carve out" permitting the Firm to go to court for injunctive relief to prevent disclosure of attorney client AND other confidential information.

- The agreement precluded administrative proceedings before the U.S. DOL and the California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, while allowing administrative charges to be filed at the EEOC and California DFEH.

So, it's time to tune up those arbitration agreements again.

DGV

Compete, Yes, But Don't Breach Duty of Loyalty

Competition is favored in California. But agents (including employees) cannot divert customers to another employer while still in an agency / employee relationship. Employees are free to leave, but while they remain employed, they owe a duty of loyalty to their employers. The Court of Appeal upheld a preliminary injunction where a business seller, retained as "managing agents" of the sold business, breached the duty of loyalty by diverting business to a third party. The case is Huong Que v. Luu.

DGV

9th Circuit: California Law Prohibits Hiring Away "For Cause" Employees

CRST is a trucking company. It had one-year contracts with new employees. CRST provided significant training to the new employees and wanted them to remain employed so they got their money's worth. CRST limited its right to terminate the employees' employment during the one-year initial agreement. In exchange, if the employees left voluntarily within the year, they refunded training costs.

Werner hired away CRST employees while they were under contract. CRST sued Werner for interference with CRST's contracts (of which Werner was aware). The Ninth Circuit held that the complaint stated a cause of action under California law governing interference with contract, and unfair business practices under California's unfair competition law. CRST Van Expedited, Inc. v. Werner Enterprises.

For employers willing to forgo "at will" employment, this case may effectively protect their investment in training and recruiting workers. The Court did not address any of Werner's potential defenses, including the privilege of competition under California law. It could be this case is another option for employers in California who cannot tie employees via non-competition agreements. Maybe employers can use renewable three-month contracts instead, so bad employees may be discharged at the end of the three-month period? The case probably has no effect when the employee chooses to leave, however. We'll see.

Friday, May 25, 2007

Proposed FEHA Amendment: "Familial Status" Discrimination

This week, the EEOC issued new "ENFORCEMENT GUIDANCE: UNLAWFUL DISPARATE TREATMENT OF WORKERS WITH CAREGIVING RESPONSIBILITIES." The EEOC recognizes it can't create new discrimination criteria not in Title VII. However, the agency explains, discrimination against those who care for family members or against those who care for individuals with disabilities may constitute discrimination. Much of this guidance deals with "work/family" conflict, and the effect of gender stereotypes associated with assumptions about familial responsibilities.

Coincidentally(?), the California Senate introduced SB 836, adding a new protected category to the Fair Employment and Housing Act: "familial status." Familial status is vaguely defined as "an individual who is or who will be caring for or supporting a family member." "Family member" means child, spouse, domestic partner, parent, parent-in-law, or grandchild.

Most of us fall (or will fall) within this new category. Congratulations. So, if the bill passes, will those ineligible for FMLA/CFRA have a new way of proving discrimination? Does "caring for" mean permanently, or just one day of care?

Stay tuned.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

New California Case: Prevent Workplace Violence

Plaintiff Franklin alleged that a coworker in the workplace had threatened to have three other employees and him killed, that defendants did nothing in response to his complaint to them about the threats, that the coworker thereafter assaulted him with a screwdriver, that plaintiff reported the assault to the police, and that plaintiff was terminated from his employment as a result of his complaints to defendants and the police.

In Franklin v. The Monadnock Company, the Court of Appeal held that these allegations were sufficient to support a claim for wrongful termination in violation of public policy. The public policy? The employer's duty to provide a safe workplace.

This case will support employers' arguments that there should be little to no tolerance for violent threats or conduct. Therefore, there should not be a duty to provide a "reasonable accommodation" for violent misconduct. However, employers face some mixed signals on that point.

The best way to prevent a claim for workplace violence is training supervisors to detect and respond to workplace violence symptoms, and take them seriously, and for HR managers to learn how to conduct investigations. It also helps to better understand the obligation to accommodate those employees with bona fide disabiliies that may suggest violent tendencies.

Sunday, May 13, 2007

California Court on Sexual Harassment Away from Work

When a supervisor accompanies an employee to events away from the workplace, claims for sexual harassment may still be available where the supervisor engages in misconduct. The Court of Appeal in Myers v. Trendwest Resorts reversed summary judgment in favor of the employer.

The court of appeal examined recent California Supreme Court authority and decided that Myers should be permitted to proceed against Trendwest. Myers' supervisor, Damlahki, engaged in conduct Myers claimed created a hostile work environment. The most serious allegations, however, occurred away from the workplace. Damlahki and plaintiff were on a job assignment and went to Damlahki's house. In the garage, Damlahki groped plaintiff etc. Another incident occurred at a social outing.

Trendwest's main argument was that it could not be liable for harassment that occurred outside the scope of Damlahki's employment. Trendwest argued it did not approve of the job assignment away from work, nor did it sponsor social drinking activities other than its holiday party. The Court of Appeal said that under recent case law,
The trial court erred because, in order for the employer to avoid strict liability for the supervisor’s actions under the FEHA, the harassment must result from a completely private relationship unconnected with the employment. Otherwise, the employer is strictly liable for the supervisor’s actions regardless of whether the supervisor was acting as the employer’s agent.
The employee's failure to complain, the company's anti-harassment policy, and the employee's agreement to accompany the supervisor on a weekend to Las Vegas (which did not occur), were all irrelevant. The fact that the incident in the garage occurred as the outcropping of a work-related drive was sufficient to confer liability on Trendwest. This standard is much broader than is applicable under traditional claims asserted against employers for conduct by employees. Employers must educate managers that they do not check their supervisory status at the plant gates and that their conduct away from work involving other employees may give rise to liability.

California Court: Employer Failed to Follow CFRA Requirements

The California Family Rights Act in most respects mirrors the federal FMLA. These laws have been around for some time now. But their provisions, and the interplay between them and workers' compensation and disability discrimination laws, continue to vex employers. The California Court of Appeal's decision in Faust v. California Portland Cement is a cautionary tale for employers trying to untangle this complex web of laws and regulations.

Faust worked for California Portland Cement as a "lube specialist" at a quarry. He experienced some severe stress and work and filed a worker's compensation claim. He sent in an initial note note in support of a request for leave based on depression. His psych benefits ended. He then sought an extension supported by a note from his chiropractor.

The employer questioned the adequacy of the certificate and attempted to call Faust. His wife told the HR manager that Faust was too stressed to speak with the HR manager, and she could speak with Mrs. Faust, Faust's workers' compensation lawyer, or his chiropractor. The company did not accept these options and terminated Faust's employment after seven weeks of leave. Significantly, the company also did not designate the leave as CFRA/FMLA, or notify Faust of his rights under those laws.

Faust sued for disability discrimination and harassment under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, as well as denial of CFRA leave, interference with the right to take CFRA leave, retaliation, and unfair business practices in violation of California Bus. and Prof. Code section 17200. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the company, holding that Faust had engaged in "insubordination" by taking unauthorized leave. The trial court's main point was that Faust did not cooperate with the company's efforts to clarify the bases for his leave.

The Court of Appeal reversed on the CFRA claims. Here are the important issues decided:

1. Interference with CFRA merely requires proof that the employee was entitled to leave and the employer denied the leave. There is no "pretext" or "shifting burdens" analysis normally applicable to discrimination claims.

2. The company's failure to demonstrate it had (1) posted the required notices regarding FMLA/ CFRA leave, and (2) notified Faust of his right to CFRA leave precluded summary judgment against Faust. The CFRA regulations expressly state the employer's failure to give notice precludes the employer from denying leave because the employee failed to give adequate notice.

3. The court would not hold that, as a matter of law, the company was privileged to insist on speaking with Faust directly, rather than his wife, doctor or workers' compensation attorney. This is significant, as employees frequently refer management to "representatives," and employers frequently (and correctly) insist on communication with their own employee. The court said that whether Faust adequately communicated is for the trier of fact (likely a jury made up of 12 employees who may not want to talk with HR.)

4. The chiropractor's note, while perhaps not adequate to constitute a medical certification, was more than sufficient to put the employer on notice that it should look further into whether the leave qualified under CFRA. The court then said that the company's efforts were insufficient because it did not seek out Faust's designated representatives, and that the company failed to give Faust notice of leave anyway.

5. The retaliation claim survived because the company's legitimate business reason was undermined by the fact that the company would not communicate with any of Faust's representatives, "particularly" his workers' compensation attorney. The court said that this failure was sufficient to permit a trial on whether the discharge was in retaliation for Faust's taking a protected leave.

6. The wrongful termination in violation of public policy claim survived because the CFRA claim survived. But the court noted in a footnote that Faust's reporting co-worker misconduct would not support that wrongful termination claim. That footnote will come in handy for employers in other contexts.

7. The court finally allowed the FEHA disability discrimination claim to proceed. With little analysis, the court relied on Faust's discrediting the company's legitimate business reason for discharging him, as discussed above.

It is always much easier to analyze these issues in hindsight. The company did try to assess Faust's entitlement to leave, and Faust did not fully cooperate. But, as this decision makes clear, the law places most of the burden on the employer to ferret out whether employees are entitled to protected leave. So, the decision might have come out better for the employer if it had (1) taken into account Faust's initial claim of a mental disability when refusing to deal with the "representatives" and (2) provided notice of CFRA leave at the outset of Faust's leave.

DGV

Friday, May 11, 2007

California Supreme Court Takes Up Unique Disability Discrimination Case

I covered Roby v. McKesson here in December. The California Supreme Court agreed to hear the case, which means the lower court's opinion no longer may be cited as precedent. Here is the issue on appeal:

This case presents the following issues: (1) In an action for employment discrimination and harassment by hostile work environment, does Reno v. Baird (1998) 18 Cal.4th 640 require that the claim for harassment be established entirely by reference to a supervisor's acts that have no connection with matters of business and personnel management, or may such management-related acts be considered as part of the totality of the circumstances allegedly creating a hostile work environment? (2) May an appellate court determine the maximum constitutionally permissible award of punitive damages when it has reduced the accompanying award of compensatory damages, or should the court remand for a new determination of punitive damages in light of the reduced award of compensatory damages?

So, the Court has agreed to decide if "harassment" is conduct separate and apart from managers' personnel decisions, or whether personnel decisions (demotion, discipline, etc.) can form part of a "harassment" claim. Check back in a couple of years for the exciting conclusion!

DGV

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

A Pot Pourri of Shaw Valenza's Articles Published in 2007

Here are some articles we've written since the beginning of the year, all of which are posted here on our website -

EMPLOYERS MUST COMPLY WITH STATE LAWS ON MEAL BREAKS, REST PERIODS
By D. Gregory Valenza, published in the San Francisco Daily Journal 4 May 2007

California employers must furnish employees with both rest periods, which are paid, and meal periods, which are not paid. These requirements first appeared in the Industrial Welfare Commission's Wage Orders in 1916. But in 2000, the Legislature imposed on employers significant financial consequences for failure to comply with rest and meal period laws.

THE EVOLUTION OF CALIFORNIA LABOR CODE SECTION 132A
By Jennifer Brown Shaw and Becki Graham, published in The Daily Recorder 25 April 2007

The California Constitution mandates a form of workers’ compensation outside of the common law remedies available in civil lawsuits. The Legislature has implemented this public policy so the workers’ compensation system is the preferred means to remedy employees’ work-related injuries.

POTENTIAL LIABILITY FOR EMPLOYER-SPONSORED SOCIAL EVENTS
By Jennifer Brown Shaw and Carolyn Burnette, published in The Daily Recorder 11 April 2007

In general, an employer may be liable for employee conduct at a social event (both negligent and intentional) whenever such conduct is “within the course and scope of employment.”

ALTERNATIVE WORKWEEKS
By D. Gregory Valenza and Matthew J. Norfleet, published in the San Francisco Daily Journal 6 April 2007

The eight-hour workday is a founding principle of organized labor in the United States. The famous Haymarket Square riots in Chicago in 1886 resulted in the deaths of seven police officers when one of the attendees threw a bomb at the advancing riot squad. Although there was no evidence that union leaders threw the bomb or even knew of its existence, they were executed for inciting the riot by holding a rally for an eight-hour day...

"EXEMPT" STATUS UNDER CALIFORNIA LAW: AVOID THE PITFALLS"
By Jennifer Brown Shaw, published in The Daily Recorder, 28 March 2007

In the past several years, California employers have struggled to understand which of their employees may be properly classified as “exempt” under California law. Those employees are “exempt” from minimum wage and overtime (and other compensation, such as reporting time and call back pay), and required to take rest breaks and meal periods. Part of the confusion stems from the fact that the requirements for exempt status under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) are different in many ways from the California requirements. While these differences are not new, the recent flood of class action litigation regarding which employees are properly due overtime necessarily has generated keen interest in compliance.

A NEW LOOK AT PAID LEAVE UNDER THE FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE ACT
By Jennifer Brown Shaw, published in The Daily Recorder 14 March 2007

In a nutshell, the FMLA provides up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave to eligible employees. Eligible employees are those who have been employed for at least a year, have 1250 hours of service with the employer, and are employed at a worksite where 50 or more employees work within a 75-mile radius. The California Family Rights Act (“CFRA”) provides similar leave. In general, the laws are considered parallel. But there are significant exceptions, particularly with respect to the treatment of leave due to pregnancy disability.

A CHECKLIST FOR PREVENTING HUMAN RESOURCES PROBLEMS
By Jennifer Brown Shaw, published in The Daily Recorder, 28 February 2007

Management concerned with employment law liability should be focused on prevention: preventing lawsuits, preventing employee morale problems, and preventing the day-to-day hassles personnel issues can create. The road to success in this area is not paved with good intentions, however. Employers must understand basic human resources principles to avoid the employment law pitfalls that await.

MILITARY PERSONNEL HAVE JOB PROTECTION RIGHTS WHEN CALLED TO DUTY
By Jennifer Brown Shaw, published in The Daily Recorder, 13 February 2007

With the still unresolved political question of whether to “escalate” or “withdraw” from the Iraq war, America’s service men and women continue to be called away from their civil jobs to assist with the war effort. At least one source reports that, since September 11, 2001, approximately 550,000 reservists and members of the National Guard have been called to active duty. Of those, 475,000 have returned to the civilian work force.

EFFECTIVE EMPLOYEE TRAINING PROGRAMS: MONEY IN THE BANK
By Jennifer Brown Shaw, published in The Daily Recorder, 30 January 2007

What can employers do to reduce their potential exposure for workplace related claims? Adopting and fairly administering lawful policies and procedures is a good start, of course. However, employers also must take the next step to train employees about what is expected of them and the options available for resolving workplace issues within the organization.

Happy reading!

DGV

Thursday, May 03, 2007

California Supreme Court Upcoming Hearings

The California Supreme Court will deliver major rulings this summer.


PRACHASAISORADEJ v. RALPHS GROCERY will be heard on June 6. This case is critically important to all employers who provide employees with bonuses based on profitability. The Court is deciding if a bonus based on profits is illegal because it takes into account workers' compensation costs by necessity because such costs are included in profit calculations.


GENTRY v. S.C. (CIRCUIT CITY STORES) will be heard on June 5. This case examines whether class action waivers in employment agreements are enforceable. The court already has held in another case that class action waivers in consumer class actions are not. This case is different because of the value of the claims at issue, whcih are much higher than in the credit card fee case previously decided.

GREEN v. CALIFORNIA will be heard on May 31. This case addresses who the burden of proof in disability discrimination cases. Does the plaintiff have to prove that he or she could perform the essential functions of the job as part of the prima facie case? Or does the employer have to prove that the plaintiff could not do so as an affirmative defense?

The Court must issue an opinion within 90 days of oral argument. So, this summer will be full of opportunities for celebration or misery, depending on the opinions issued. And we will be there with blog postings, articles, and legal updates. But you knew that.

DGV

Thursday, April 19, 2007

California Arbitration Agreements Do Not Always Have to Comply with Armendariz

In California, arbitration agreements will be deemed "unconscionable" if they concern discrimination or "public policy" causes of action, unless they comply with the procedural requirements set forth in Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare Services.

Armendariz requires, among other things, "neutral arbitrators, more than minimal discovery, a written award, and all of the types of relief that would otherwise be available in court and, in addition, "'do[] not require employees to pay either unreasonable costs or any arbitrators’ fees or expenses as a condition of access to the arbitration forum.'"

Many an arbitration agreement has been invalidated under Armendariz, either because the arbitration agreement shifted costs to the employee, did not provide for discovery, or unduly limited remedies. There also is the argument that Armendariz requires "mutuality," which means that if an agreement is not entirely mutual, it is invalid as unconscionable.

Well, in Giuliano v. Inland Empire Personnel, the plaintiff sued for breach of contract, alleging he was not paid bonuses or severance to which he was entitled. He signed an arbitration agreement that probably would have failed under Armendariz. But the Court of Appeal here said that because no FEHA or public policy claim was at issue, Armendariz did not apply.

This decision is significant, because many employers are sued for breach of contract, fraud, and other causes of action not involving discrimination or harassment If Armendariz does not apply, employers will have significant freedom to include in these arbitration agreements terms that would not normally be upheld under Armendariz, e.g., a waiver of entitlement to punitive or tort damages, short statute of limitations, carve-outs permitting the employer to seek injunctive relief, etc. Employers seeking to change arbitration provisions must have them carefully reviewed by counsel - not kidding.

DGV

Monday, April 16, 2007

Ca Supreme Court: Three-Year Statute of Limitations for Meal Periods Claims

Murphy v. Kenneth Cole Productions was supposed to be the case in which the California Supreme Court once and for all held that meal period penalties are in fact penalties and not wages. Wrong again! The high court unanimously held that meal period premiums are "wages," not penalties. So much for all the press on the hotly divided court at oral argument.

Anyway, so what? Well.....wage claims are covered by a three-year statute of limitations; penalty claims are covered by a one-year statute. Three years is three times longer than one year, which may result in larger claims and larger awards .

If you care about such things, this case kind of smarts. But wait...there's more.

The Supreme Court also held that appeals of Labor Commissioner decisions to Superior Courts may include new claims not litigated on the administrative level. That means that employees may lose a claim at the Labor Commissioner level, appeal, and assert entirely new theories in court for the first time as part of the simple appeal "de novo" process. I suppose it also means that employers may appeal Labor Commissioner decisions and face entirely new claims at the Superior Court level.

DGV

Monday, April 09, 2007

One for the Employment Litigators

The plaintiff sued the SF Housing authority and lost. (Demps v. SF Housing Authority). Employment law practitioners will like the thorough legal discussion of the retaliation claim. This also is one of the rare opinions where the court said that the plaintiff failed to make out a prima facie case of discrimination because the plaintiff "was not performing competently."

Also - the court in Demps finally overruled its old decision in Biljac Associates v. First Interstate Bank. No longer may trial courts refuse to rule on objections to evidence at summary judgment hearings by saying, "I'm only relying on admissible evidence."

Disclosure of employees' names and addresses in wage/hour class actions upheld

Employers involved in wage and hour class actions likely will NOT be able to successfully object to (pre-certification) disclosure of names and addresses of putative class members.

We previously covered Pioneer Electronics v. Superior Court (Olmstead), in which the California Supreme Court said that disclosure of class contact information was OK if the putative class member had the opportunity to "opt out" of disclosure. But Pioneer was a consumer class action, not an employment law case. Everyone knows employees have reasonable expectations of privacy in personnel information. Employment cases are different. Pioneer won't apply, right?

Wrong. The Court of Appeal in Belaire-West Landscape v. Superior Court (Rodriguez) applied Pioneer to a wage and hour class action. The Court briefly touched on the difference between an employee's privacy interest in personnel records voluntarily disclosed to an employer, but basically said that the ability to "opt out" of disclosure was sufficient protection of that privacy interest.

The disclosure of putative class members' names and addresses may be significant, depending on how the plaintiffs' bar uses the information. Maybe there will be a backlash against the plaintiffs' bar for bothering employees at home. Maybe plaintiffs will submit a lot more hostile declarations in support of class certification motions. Time will tell.

DGV

Thursday, March 22, 2007

Immigration is a hot employment law issue too

Two recent cases examine the intersection of immigration law and employment litigation and both decisions are in favor of the immigrants.

First, California employment law does not make distinctions between employees working lawfully or illegally. Labor Code 1171.5 plainly declares:

(a) All protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals
regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or
who have been employed, in this state. (b) For purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, a person's immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability,and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person's immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.

In Reyes v. Van Elk, the California Court of Appeal held that section 1171.5 is not preempted by federal immigration laws. Reyes and others accused Van Elk of failing to pay the "prevailing wage." The Superior Court held that federal immigration law preempted section 1171.5 and that Reyes could not seek unpaid prevailing wages because he was an illegal immigrant. The court of appeal reversed, holding that federal law (IRCA) does not preempt section 1171.5, and that Reyes had standing to sue for unpaid wages.

Second, in a case having broad implications for employers hiring workers under immigration visas such as H1-B's, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that an employer could be held liable for wrongfully discharging an employee who was not authorized to work in the U.S. The case is Incalza v. Fendi. Incalza worked for Fendi under an E-1 visa. When a French company bought Fendi, the E-1 visa no longer was valid. Fendi, which did apparently not want to retain Incalza anyway, discharged him because he was not lawfully working in the U.S. Incalza asked for a leave of absence to obtain a visa or to marry his fiance, a U.S. citizen.

Incalza sued for breach of contract not to terminate without good cause, among other things. Fendi argued that "good cause" was established because Incalza was not lawfully allowed to work, and Fendi was not obligated to wait until Incalza became authorized to work. A jury found in favor of Incalza. Fendi appealed and ran right into Stephen Reinhardt.

The Court of Appeals said that IRCA does not require employers to terminate workers who may resolve immigration status if they are granted a leave of absence. Does the law require granting a leave of absence? No, but this did not stop the Court of Appeals. The Court said that an employee on leave is not actually "employed" under IRCA. (This is news to employers who must provide all sorts of leaves with guaranteed reinstatement.) Because the employee is not really "employed" while on leave, the court reasoned, the employer can comply with IRCA and not discharge the worker.

Distinguishing Supreme Court authority and the IRCA statute itself, the Court announced this rule: "as a general rule, individuals who are indisputably not authorized to work must be discharged immediately. An individual who has the opportunity to switch from an E-1 to an H1-B . . . is, however, another matter."

Incidentally, the court also held that IRCA does not conflict with Lab. Code section 1171.5, just as the state court in Van Elk did. So, that issue is settled unless the Supremes take up Fendi.

In light of this case, employers seeking to discharge employees must carefully examine whether to use the expiration of a visa as the sole justification for termination. The courts may well say that it was not "necessary" to discharge the worker merely because he or she no longer was authorized to work in the U.S.

Stay tuned.

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Ninth Circuit Protects Employee's Violent Outbursts

An employee claiming "bi-polar" disorder was privileged to storm out of the boss' office, throw papers at the boss, and kick and toss objects around her cubicle, according to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Gambini received a warning for her attitude. She claims she had bi-polar disorder. During the meeting over the warning, she became upset, left the meeting, and then started kicking her cubicle and throwing objects. Employees complained they were in fear of her next outburst. The Company hospitalized her and provided FMLA paperwork. They later terminated her employment.

Gambini sued and lost the case at trial. In Gambini v. Total Renal Care, deciding the case under Washington law (but tracking its own ADA jurisprudence), the Court of Appeals said that the jury should have been instructed that "if it found that her conduct at issue was caused by or was part of her disability, then it could find that one of the substantial reasons she was fired was her bi-polar condition."

That means the jury has to consider whether the conduct at issue is associated with a mental disability that cannot be seen or really measured. Is the conduct a result of an impairment, or just the result of a bad day, or someone emboldened by ADA protection maybe?

Consider a state like California where nearly every condition is a disability. Any conduct an employee can attribute to a disability is protected? What if the employee's symptoms include breaking things or setting them on fire? What if the employee "because" of a disability does not control bodily functions? How about touching other employees? Cursing? Taking unannounced days off?

Yes, these examples are subject to an "undue hardship" analysis, but the employer has the burden of proving undue hardship, and it's a tough burden. Direct threat? Even tougher! What if the employer fired twenty people without disabilities for throwing objects at a supervisor? The person with a disability gets a pass? I understand there are folks with real disabilities who need a boost. But I don't think the ADA was intended to be stretched in this fashion. Additionally, the opportunity for abuse is pretty high with a decision like this.

Tiny bright spot for the employer - the Ninth Circuit said that the FMLA claim was properly dismissed because the employer showed it would have fired Gambini regardless of her having taken leave.


DGV

Saturday, March 03, 2007

California Final Final Sexual Harassment Training Regs Issued

The Fair Employment and Housing Commission responded to the concerns of the Office of Administrative Law by issuing revised final AB 1825 regulations. There are refinements regarding who will be eligible to design and present AB 1825 training.

Yes, we're still qualified. We think.

But employers looking to conduct their training in house, and those evaluating third-party vendors, should carefully review these regulations to ensure that the designer and presenter is qualified under the new regulations.

DGV

California DLSE Changes View on Professional Exemption

The California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement has revised its Enforcement and Interpretations Manual regarding some aspects of the "professional exemption." The DLSE's enforcement position is consistent with the DOL regulations as they existed before the revisions in 2004.

In particular, the DLSE clarified that the "learned" professional exemption now requires learning only above the high school level. The manual does not say it is necessary for exempt employees to have post-bachelor's degrees. If you haven't fallen asleep yet, you can view the manual here. Turn to chapter 54, which is at page 236 of 303 on your Acrobat reader....

DGV

California Employers Cannot Require Employees to Use Vacation During FMLA Leave

FMLA leave is generally unpaid. The FMLA generally provides employers with the right to require employees to use vacation and sick leave (or other paid leave) during FMLA-covered leave. But there are some rather badly written DOL regulations that restrict the employer's right to when leave is "unpaid." And when an employee receives benefits such as under a temporary disability leave benefit plan the leave is not "unpaid" and the employer cannot require the employee to use vacation or sick pay. The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals recently applied that regulation in Repa v. Roadway Express, Inc. The effect of the decision is that California employers cannot require employees to use vacation, sick or other paid leave when the employee is receiving state disability, PFL, or workers' compensation benefits. If you need more information on this, we will have an article posted on our website about it next week.

DGV

Friday, February 16, 2007

Congress Considering "Card Check" Bill to Increase Unionization

According to these interesting data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, about 7% of the private sector employees are unionized; that number is about 36% for government employees. So, many don't pay attention updates like this. That may change soon. Congress is interested in increasing that percentage.

Here's a quick and oversimplified overview of union organizing under current laws:

When unions attempt to organize employees, they collect "authorization cards" from employees. Once they obtain enough cards, they typically present them to the employer and demand the right to bargain. (Some unions go straight to the NLRB and petition for an election). But the employer can reject the cards and demand a secret ballot election usually conducted by the National Labor Relations Board. Once the Board processes a petition for an election, the union and employer have about six weeks to "campaign" until the election. The union and the employer present their respective cases, and the employees vote in a secret ballot. The NLRB counts the votes. Unions and their advocates argue this election process deters unionization because employers use unfair or illegal election tactics. Employers argue they and the unions present the facts and let the employees decide. About half the time, the employees decide against the union. Unions don't like that success rate.

So, apparently a majority of the House of Representatives would like to skip all that secret ballot election stuff and let the union obtain representation rights just by collecting authorization cards. HR 800, The Employee Free Choice Act would do just that.

It's a lot easier to organize employees when the employer does not get a chance to explain why union representation is not a good idea. And the First Amendment gives unions a free reign on what they can say to obtain a signature on an authorization card. I bet peer pressure increases the number of signatures. Organizers' unchallenged promises about the benefits of unions help, and there could even be some signature hanky-panky once in a while too. (Such a cynic).

No one is paying attention to the rest of the Bill, though. Another section would require unions and employers to mediate and then arbitrate if negotiations do not quickly result in a new collective bargaining agreement. Lots of power in the hands of one arbitrator to unilaterally "impose" an agreement. Another provision imposes penalties of up to $20,000 per violation of "unfair labor practices" committed by employers before the first collective bargaining agreement is signed.

This Bill is not new. But with the power shift in Congress, this year it is gaining traction. Vice President Cheney has said publicly it will be vetoed if passed. But sometimes deals are made.... So stay tuned.

Saturday, February 10, 2007

AB 1825 Harassment Training Regulations Disapproved

The California Fair Employment and Housing Commission's regulations implementing AB 1825 (mandatory sexual harassment training) failed to gain approval from California's Office of Administrative Law. The FEHC made the announcement here.

The OAL's chief concern was that the regulations were not sufficiently "clear" in certain respects, particularly regarding who is qualified to prepare and conduct anti-harassment training under the statute. There were also some more technical flaws.

The FEHC plans to modify the regulations and publish them for a brief public comment period
before re-submitting them to the OAL. The FEHC's modifications may have a significant effect on existing programs, depending on whether the new standards "raise the bar" on who is qualified to prepare or conduct AB 1825 training.

Once the regulations are re-issued, employers should reevaluate whether their trainers and training programs meet the new standards.

DGV

Ninth Circuit Explains "Regarded As" Claims under the ADA

An employer's acknowledgement that an employee has an "impairment" is not enough to support a claim that the employee is "regarded as" having a disability.
Walton v. U.S. Marshall Service involves a former security guard at a federal courthouse. The essential functions of the job include the ability to "localize" sound. Walton had only one functioning ear, which affected her ability to localize sound. After a required medical exam, the security services contractor terminated Walton's employment because she could not perform essential functions of her job. She claimed the contractor "regarded" her as having a disability.
The Ninth Circuit held:
to state a "regarded as" claim a plaintiff must establish that the employer believes that the plaintiff has some impairment, and provide evidence that the employer subjectively believes that the plaintiff is substantially limited in a major life activity. If the plaintiff does not have direct evidence of the employer's subjective belief that the plaintiff is substantially limited in a major life activity, the plaintiff must further provide evidence that the impairment imputed to the plaintiff is, objectively, a substantially limiting impairment.
Applying this rule, the Court of Appeals decided that the employer's actions demonstrated only that the employer regarded the employee as having an "impairment," but there was no evidence the employer considered the impairment to be "substantially limiting" in one or more major life activities.

Employers often ask whether exploring the possibility of accommodation, asking an employee to have a fitness for duty examination, or otherwise acknowledging medical impairments will create "regarded as" liability. This decision makes it harder for plaintiffs to make that argument under the ADA and federal Rehabilitation Act.

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Ninth Circuit Affirms Order Certifying Huge Class Action Against Walmart

A couple of years ago, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California certified a class of female employees against Walmart. The case was noteworthy because it is a nationwide class action in which the plaintiffs claim Walmart discriminates against female employees in setting compensation, making promotion decisions and other issues. The class size was estimated at 1.5 million workers.

Walmart appealed the class certification order. The Ninth Circuit heard oral argument in August 2005, and finally issued its opinion today. A three judge panel voted 2-1 to affirm the district court's decision. Barring settlement or a successful decertification of the class, the huge class action against Walmart will proceed to trial.

DGV

Friday, February 02, 2007

Another San Francisco Paid Sick Leave Update

The San Francisco Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE) has come up with some FAQs regarding the San Francisco paid sick leave ordinance. The FAQs give some insight as to the city's enforcement position. The answers to some of the questions will confirm that the ordinance is nearly impossible for large employers with operations within and without San Francisco to comply with. The law goes into effect this Monday, February 5, 2007. Good luck!

DGV

Frere Jacques, Dormez-vous?

Now and then one should look beyond California's borders for employment law trendzzzzz. So, according to this article in the San Francisco Chronicle, France's health ministry is looking into whether to mandate nap time for workers. With their 35 hour workweek and months of vacation, sick time, etc., the stress of finding things to do in one's spare time apparently causes sleepless nights for French workers. OK, I'm a little jealous. There is no truth to the rumor that San Francisco is considering mandating juice and cookies. Yet.

DGV

Thursday, January 25, 2007

California Supreme Court Approves Pre-Class Certification Disclosure of Putative Class Members

Class actions often involve discovery battles over the identification of potential class members before a class is certified. The plaintiff wants to be able to contact freely potentially sympathetic witnesses to support the certification motion and win on the merits. The defendant typically wants to preclude the plaintiff from contacting these putative class members since they often are completely unaware of the lawsuit asserted on their behalf.

The California Supreme Court in Pioneer Electronics (USA), Inc. v. Superior Court (Olmstead)endorsed pre-certification identification of putative class members. The Court rejected the court of appeal's procedure for contacting witnesses - a letter permitting contact only if the potential class member affirmatively consented to the disclosure of his or her information. Rather, the Supreme Court favored the trial court's procedure - contact information would be disclosed unless the putative class member objected to the disclosure by returning the letter sent by the parties, checking a box denying consent to disclosure.

The Pioneer case is not an employment law decision per se; the case involved claims that a Pioneer DVD player was defective. And the Supreme Court did not mention disclosure of information in personnel files, or employment class actions, even though the employment bar has been waiting for this decision for a couple of years, and an employers' association filed an amicus brief.

There is little good news for employers in the opinion. However, there is language in the decision supporting more protection when plaintiffs in class action seek employees' contact information or disclosure of information from personnel files. Unlike in the consumer class action context, employees' personnel files are protected from disclosure by statute and have been recognized as information entitled to constitutional protection. Therefore, the courts interpreting Pioneer may well adopt more stringent procedures for identification of information in personnel files.

We will see how this shakes out.

DGV

New Trend Emerging: Anti-"Bullying" Laws

Nobody likes a mean boss. Co-workers naturally do not always like everyone they work with. But a recent San Francisco Chronicle article features the possibility of anti-bullying legislation.
The website "bullybusters.org" contains a growing list of states taking up "model" healthy workplace legislation.

Anti-bullying laws would mean that someone could claim a "hostile environment" without showing a linkage between the conduct and a protected criterion, such as race, sex, disability, religion, etc.

Rhetorical question alert: Think this could increase litigation? Think opportunistic workers will file suits against managers in retaliation for legitimate decision-making?

What does this mean? The case law currently includes many statements by courts to the effect of: "the law does not guarantee a Utopian workplace," that feuds between employees (unrelated to illegal discrimination) are not actionable, and that anti-discrimination laws are not "civility codes." Well, if anti-bully advocates have their way, all these dicta in judicial opinions will become obsolete.

The devil of course is in the details. Everyone understands that an abusive person in the workplace is not conducive to good morale, can result in higher turnover, and can make going to work unpleasant etc. (More rhetorical questions follow). But when does an "intense" manager or employee cross the line and become a "bully' subjecting the employer to financial liability? And who is going to decide this? A jury at a cost of tens or hundreds of thousands in legal fees? How will managers be able to manage poor performance, convey negative feedback, and even let off a little steam without the fear of legal liability? And then there's the backlash - Won't it be easier just to fire an at-will employee than let the worker build a "bullying" case?

Workers have arguments now and then. Supervisors are responsible for managing productivity, work performance, attendance, and other unpopular subjects which naturally cause hurt feelings. Should managers be legally required to be nice? Should managers hire people based on whether they are likely to be friendly? Incidentally, should an employee be injured by such conduct, there already is a remedy for physical or psychiatric through the workers' compensation laws.

So, let's hope that the advocates of anti-bullying legislation consider the various issues that anti-bullying legislation will raise, and set a relatively high standard for what is a "bully."

DGV

Sunday, January 21, 2007

Nevada Minimum Wage Increases to $6.15

Employers dealing with California's myriad employment laws may have missed Nevada's minimum wage increase, which actually took effect a couple of months ago.

The new minimum wage of $6.15 applies only to employees who are not covered by the employer's health insurance program. The Nevada minimum wage remains at $5.15 for those who are covered by health care insurance. Here's an AP article.

Fun fact: Nevada hasn't updated its regulations on the web yet. So, the official text says that the minimum wage remains at $5.15. However, the Nevada Labor Commissioner's FAQ's reflect the new figure.

Federal fact: The federal minimum wage is $5.15, but Congress is contemplating a substantial increase this year, perhaps as much as $7.25.

DGV

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

San Francisco Paid Sick Leave Update

We previously posted about the new paid sick leave ordinance and poster here. There are subtle differences in the language between the ordinance and poster, intended to "clarify" the ordinance. For example, employers may be surprised to know that San Francisco's Office of Labor Standards Enforcement takes the position that paid sick leave must accrue when any employee performs work in San Francisco, even if only temporarily. Once the employee works 30 hours in San Francisco, no matter the time it takes to do so, the employee accrues an hour of paid sick leave. On the other hand, the employee is entitled to take paid sick leave only when scheduled to work in San Francisco.

So, for example, assume an employee based in Oakland comes into San Francisco for a two hour meeting. The employer must track that time so that the employee earns sick leave after 28 more hours performing work in San Francisco. Other examples - a delivery driver spends 3 hours out of 8 delivering in San Francisco per day, or a salesperson whose territory includes San Francisco and others. In each case, the employer is responsible for toting up the hours worked in SF and crediting one hour's sick pay for each 30 hours of work within the City and County of San Francisco.

Obviously, employees who do not regularly work in SF will not accrue much sick time, and probably won't have much opportunity to take it. But this will be a recordkeeping nightmare. The ordinance is effective on 2/5. Get ready!

Tuesday, January 09, 2007

California Proposed Regs re Expense Reimbursement

California's Division of Labor Standards Enforcement has decided to issue proposed regulations on the reimbursement of employee expenses under Labor Code section 2802. The regulations cover travel and personal automobile expenses, meal reimbursement, and other reimbursement issues. The regulations specifically authorize the DLSE to take expense reimbursement claims at the agency level and provides for attorneys' fees to be awarded in favor of employees based on a "lodestar" formula. There will be a comment period and revisions before these are finalized.

DGV

Thursday, January 04, 2007

Update on San Francisco Sick Leave - Poster

Here is the poster for San Francisco's Paid Sick Leave ordinance. The new law takes effect February 5, 2007. All employers with employees working in the City and County of San Francisco must comply. (Us ,too).

Resources - We posted previously on this in November. Also, here is our article we published in the Sacramento Daily Recorder. And here is the ordinance itself.

DGV

Wednesday, January 03, 2007

Employee Monitoring - California Supreme Court to Review Hernandez v. Hillsides

Happy New Year!

Back in September I posted about the California Court of Appeal's decision in Hernandez v. Hillsides. In that case, two employees were permitted to proceed with an invasion of privacy claim based on video monitoring of their office. There wasn't much monitoring and it was not directed at the employees who sued, so there was a collective shudder among employers who monitor their workers.

Fast forward to today: The California Supreme Court granted review of the case. So, nevermind about Hernandez for the next couple of years. Our advice remains the same anyway: destroy employees' expectation of privacy by giving notice of monitoring and posting signs as appropriate.

Thursday, December 28, 2006

$4 Million to California Disability Discrimination Plaintiff

McKesson Corporation is a large organization, ranking at the top of the Fortune 500. A jury in Yolo County (near Sacramento) decided the company's treatment of Charlene Roby, an employee with panic attacks, amounted to disability discrimination. So, the jury awarded $15 million in punitive damages against McKesson, on top of a multi-million dollar damages verdict.

The California Court of Appeal Roby v. McKesson HBOC reduced the verdict to about $4 million. An attorneys' fees award of $728,000 was not even challenged. The opinion primarily deals with the adjustment to the punitive damages verdict in light of recent case law setting constitutional boundaries. But if we're arguing about whether $2 million or $15 million is an appropriate punitive damages award, something went wrong from an employment law / HR management standpoint.

The plaintiff's psychological disability resulted in some unpleasant side effects, like body odor resulting from medication. In addition, her absences resulted in discipline and, ultimately, termination under a no-fault attendance policy. The evidence demonstrated that the line supervision was unsympathetic to the employee's issues. In fact, there was evidence of some outright hostility by the employee's direct supervisor. But when the employee complained after her termination, not much was done to assess the situation and ensure consistent and fair treatment. Thus, some employees received much more lenient treatment under the no-fault attendance policy. Additionally, the Company did not exempt from the attendance policy leave that fairly obviously would have qualified as FMLA/CFRA leave. A more detailed review of the application of the "rolling" no-fault attendance policy to this employee might have saved McKesson a few million. Under the disability discrimination laws, mechanical application of attendance policies may be hazardous to the balance sheet.

Silver lining - the court held that there was insufficient evidence of a hostile work environment, resulting in vacatur of about $1.1 million of the award. There was indeed evidence of "hostility" and some mistreatment. However, it was not sufficiently "severe or pervasive" to sustain the jury's verdict. Additionally, the court distinguished between conduct that will support a "harassment" claim, and personnel actions, which do not constitute "harassment" in the legal sense. As a result of the court's findings, Roby's supervisor escaped about $500,000 in personal liability for her mistreatment of Roby.

Wednesday, December 20, 2006

Arbitration Agreements in California Set to Make a Comeback

In California, agreements to arbitrate employment claims (at least with respect to non-union employees) are not particularly in demand. California courts have removed many of the advantages employers (e.g., simpler discovery, cost-sharing, limitations on damages). Arbitration agreements that contain such provisions are struck down by courts as "unconscionable." So, the primary benefit of arbitration agreements in California is the transfer of a claim from a potentially hostile pool of employee-jurors to an arbitrator, hopefully a fair one with expertise in employment law.

Until now. Of late, courts have wrestled with the issue of whether an arbitration agreement can include a provision (1) requiring arbitration but (2) prohibiting the plaintiff from bringing a "class action." In the Discover Bank v. Superior Court(2005) 36 Cal.4th 148 case, decided last year, the California Supreme Court held that consumer class actions could not be barred by arbitration clauses. However, the High Court left the door open a crack for class action waivers in claims for larger damages - such as employment claims. The Court of Appeal in Gentry v. Superior Court(2006) 135 Cal.App.4th 944, review granted April 26, 2006, S141502 held that Discover Bank did not bar class action waivers in employment claims, but as you can see, the Supremes accepted review of that case in April 2006, rendering it not citable as authority.

Well, in Konig v. U-Haul Company of California, the California Court of Appeal again held that Discover Bank does not bar class action waivers in employment claims. Konig brought a class action against U-Haul for a varieity of alleged wage and hour violations on behalf of himself and a class of U-Haul employees. U-Haul moved the court to compel Konig to arbitrate his claims based on an arbitration agreement he signed, which included the following language: "I understand that final and binding arbitration will be the sole and exclusive remedy for any such claim or dispute against [defendant]... and that, by agreeing to use arbitration to resolve my dispute, both [defendant] and I agree to forego any right we each may have had to a jury trial on issues covered by the [U-Haul Arbitration Policy], and forego any right to bring claims on a representative, class member basis, or as a private attorney general."

The Court of Appeal once again upheld this class action waiver under Discover Bank. Now before you run to your employment lawyer, a couple of caveats. First, the California Supreme Court has taken up this issue in Gentry, mentioned above. So the Supreme Court may well take this case up, too. Second, there was a dissent in this case, which makes it even more likely that the Supreme Court will accept review. So, the Supreme Court may answer the question of class action waivers once and for all within the next year or two.

Happy holidays to our readers and their families.

DGV

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Employer Not Liable to Third Party for Employee's Internet Postings

Not news: employees use the Internet at work for personal reasons. News: an employer is not liable when an employee uses the company internet connection to make threats to a third party.
Agilent employed Cameron Moore in Silicon Valley. Moore became upset with a couple of former Varian employees. He signed into an internet bulletin board regarding Varian, where he made some threatening posts against the former Varian employees. He used the handle... "crack_smoking_jesus." (I know. I just had to).

The threats came to the attention of the FBI, who traced them to Agilent. After an investigation, Agilent and the FBI confronted Moore.

The ex-Varian employees sued Moore and Agilent for, among other things, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, and other torts associated with the threatening posts. The plaintiffs claimed Agilent was aware of the postings and did not stop them.

In court, Agilent claimed it was immune from liability under a provision of the Communications Decency Act of 1996. Section 230(c)(1) of that law provides: "[n]o provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider." The statute goes on to preempt inconsistent state laws: "Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent any State from enforcing any State law that is consistent with this section. No cause of action may be brought and no liability may be imposed under any State or local law that is inconsistent with this section." The purpose of this section is to protect those who facilitate internet communication from liability when users abuse their communication privileges.

The trial court held Agilent was immune from suit and the Varian ex-employees appealed. The Court of Appeal in Delfino v. Agilent affirmed. This is the first known opinion applying the CDA's immunity to employers. In essence, the court agreed with Agilent that it was a mere passive provider of access to the internet, that the plaintiffs attempted to hold Agilent responsible as if it had published the offending statements itself, and another person actually published them (Moore).

The plaintiffs tried to bring in Agilent under state-law principles of respondeat superior and ratification, but the appellate court was unmoved. While the plaintiffs could seek damages against Moore himself, Agilent could not be held vicariously liable because the acts were performed outside the course and scope of employment. Ratification would not fly given Agilent fired Moore after learning what he did.

To ensure your internet connection does not expose your business to liability it is important to have an internet usage policy that prohibits engaging in misconduct on the internet, and provides for monitoring. The CDA apparently will provide strong protections as well. However, it bears noting that this case involves a lawsuit by third-parties, not current employees of the same company. It is too early to tell what effect the CDA will have on employment claims such as hostile environment harassment alleged to be caused by internet activity.

DGV

Sunday, December 10, 2006

Federal DOL Seeks Comments on FMLA Regulations

A regulatory agency usually seeks public comment about draft regulations before they are finalized. However, the U.S. Department of Labor has decided to handle things in reverse. The agency seeks public comment regarding the current FMLA regulations. That's right, you can weigh in on the rather broad "serious health condition" definition, the "ease" of administering "intermittent leave," the medical certification, and other topics covered by the current regulations you have come to love over the past dozen years. Here is a webpage the DOL has created for providing comments. Presumably, the DOL will review the comments to decide whether and to what extent revisions to the regulations are appropriate. (Dare to dream).

DGV

Sunday, November 26, 2006

IRS Announces 2007 Mileage Reimbursement Rate

The new IRS mileage reimbursement rate for 2007 will be $0.485 per mile for business, $0.20 for moving or medical purposes, and $0.14 for charitable purposes. The IRS bulletin announcing these changes is here.

California employers must reimburse employees for expenses they incur. The state Division of Labor Standards Enforcement accepts the IRS rate as adequate compensation for employees' use of personal automobiles. Therefore, employers should adjust the reimbursement rate effective January 1, 2007.

DGV

Final AB 1825 Sexual Harassment Training Regulations

The California Fair Employment and Housing Commission issued its final AB 1825 regulations. They can be accessed here. They will now be reviewed by the Office of Administrative Law. If they are approved, the will be submitted to the Secretary of State and become effective 30 days later. The FEHC estimates they will be effective around February 1, 2007. The final regulations are essentially the same as the last version submitted for comments in October.
Most employers that completed their initial training in 2005 will be training supervisors again in 2007. So, employers should ensure their training programs comply with the new regulations.

DGV

Monday, November 13, 2006

Get ready for more posts in 2007....

We haven't been posting a lot lately. We're saving our strength.

After years of no major federal employment laws (save last year's Pension Protection Act), Congress is changing hands. And here come the unions, trial lawyers, and politicians with some fresh ideas for employers. Here is an AP article on the subject.

Of course, having carefully studied civics as a child, I know it will take a lot of work to pass even one employee-friendly bill. (I also know that conjunctions' function is to hook up words and phrases and clauses.)

But I think even a divided Congress can pass some new employment mandates, assuming the President is willing to horse-trade a judicial appointment or a military appropriation or two.

DGV

Thursday, November 09, 2006

SF Passes Paid Sick Leave Requirement

The SF electorate passed an initiative requiring employers to provide paid sick leave to employees. Although many employers provide paid time off, the measure applies to all employers (no matter how few employees), and it includes some provisions that could affect even large employers' sick time policies. Here are some highlights:

- "Small employers" of under 10 employees (counted as any 10 employees who perform any work in a week, must provide at least 40 hours of paid sick leave; larger employers must provide at least 72 hours. Employers are invited but not required to be more generous.

- Sick leave begins accruing after 90 days of employment. An employee accrues one hour for each 30 hours' worked. The sick leave accrues until it reaches a cap of 40 hours for small businesses or 72 hours for large businesses.

- Employers that provide more PTO or sick leave than stated above under existing policies are deemed in compliance. However, employers will have to adjust policies to comply with the uses of sick leave, attendance policies, and the like.

- Sick leave may be used either for the employee's own illness, OR for the illness of a covered person: "child; parent; legal guardian or ward; sibling; grandparent; grandchild; and spouse, registered domestic partner under any state or local law, or designated person." Employees without covered relations may designate one "designated person" for whom the employee may take paid sick leave to care for.

- The sick leave appears to be available for use for absences of less than one day, including medical appointments.


- Sick leave accrues and "carries over" year to year if not used, but need not be paid out at termination. The accrual stops at the caps above (40 hours for smaller and 72 hours for larger employers).

- Employees must provide "reasonable advance notice" of the need for leave, presumably on occasions when it is used to care for others or for medical treatment. Employers may take "reasonable measures" to verify or document time off.

- Employers must maintain records for four years and make them available to the city for inspection.

- Time taken under this provision may not be counted as an attendance violation under company policy.

- Any adverse action taken within 90 days of an employee's engaging in any of a number of "protected activities" relating to this leave benefit (including filing a complaint or even telling other employees about the availability of paid sick leave) creates a rebuttable presumption of retaliation.

- There is a provision for private civil enforcement, including penalties of up to 3 times the sick pay denied for violations or $250, whichever is greater, liquidated damages of $50, interest, costs and attorneys fees. Class actions are authorized only for equitable relief, costs, and attorneys' fees. And....

- Yes, there will be a new poster required to be posted.

Employers that do business in San Francisco must address the many administrative and payroll issues attendant to this law asap. It goes into effect 90 days from November 7, or about February 5.