I just read that the U.S. Senate, via Senator Elizabeth Warren, is introducing a bill to ban the use of pre-employment credit checks altogether. The proposed bill is here.
The bill (as introduced) simply would amend the Fair Credit Reporting Act to make it illegal for employers to rely on credit reports to take adverse actions. Employees would no longer be able to consent to disclosure.
Any exceptions? Certainly. For example, credit checks will still be allowed when the position involves national security. Wait a minute there. How could credit checks possibly be relevant to national security? Could it be that an applicant's credit report has something to do with integrity? Well, Senators, maybe that's why employers find credit checks relevant to employer security. Another exception - when credit checks are required by law. Why would credit checks be required by law? The EEOC says credit checks are discriminatory. How could something discriminatory be required by law?
Anyway, that's it for exceptions. As written, this bill does not expressly create any exception for positions involving cash handling, banking, etc. If this bill is passed, unless the job is one of "national security" or unless a credit check is "required by law," the rest of you employers will be out of luck.
Employers may desire to run investigative consumer reports, credit reports and criminal background checks in part to verify information that applicants provide on their applications. Application fraud appears to be a big problem, according to surveys discussed here, and here, and here. Hey - perhaps the Senate will also introduce a bill making it illegal for applicants to lie on their employment applications! Fat chance.
This bill may not make it through either house, or it could be amended. But the trend among state and local governments is to get rid of credit checks, criminal background checks, and other pre-employment tools that help employers determine who is a financial or other risk. So, employers should keep abreast of this trend, and make plans to alter hiring practices as the law evolves.
Enjoy your holidays! Humbug.
WHAT'S NEW IN EMPLOYMENT LAW? Welcome to Shaw Law Group, PC's law blog. We will focus on employment law developments, particularly in California. Nothing in this forum should be construed as legal advice, 'cause it isn't. So, please consult your lawyer or hire us! (We typically represent employers, not employees). Also - this is a public website, so communications are not privileged. Copyright Shaw Law Group, PC © 2017. All rights reserved.
Showing posts with label background check. Show all posts
Showing posts with label background check. Show all posts
Friday, December 20, 2013
Monday, January 24, 2011
U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Background Check Questions
The U.S. Supreme Court ducked deciding whether the U.S. Constitution protects individuals' right to privacy in personal information. Instead, they "assumed" that there was such a protection and then decided that NASA's background questions were constitutional no matter what. This provoked a concurrence in the judgment only from Justice Scalia (and another, short one from Justice Thomas), as both of them wanted the court to decide the constitution contains no such right.
The employment law issue here is whether NASA's questions were appropriate issues to ask applicants and employees. Most federal government employees are subjected to a standard background check. But contract employees were only recently added, following the 9/11 attacks. NASA employed a number of contract employees at its Jet Propulsion Lab, and had to implement the checks for current employees, some of whom were employed for many years.
The questions included standard background information, but then asked about drug use, sales, etc., and asked for explanations if the employee admitted to involvement with illegal drugs. After the employee answered the questions, the agency sent out questionnaires to landlords and references on a standard form. That standard form contains a number of questions to which plaintiffs objected:
On review, the Supreme Court decided that these questions do not infringe upon privacy rights even if they were protected by the Constitution:
Of course the court did not deal with the issue of "adverse impact" discrimination claims here. But the defense to adverse impact is "job related and consistent with business necessity." Language in this opinion should help estasblish this defense.
The opinion is NASA v. Nelson and it is here.
DGV
The employment law issue here is whether NASA's questions were appropriate issues to ask applicants and employees. Most federal government employees are subjected to a standard background check. But contract employees were only recently added, following the 9/11 attacks. NASA employed a number of contract employees at its Jet Propulsion Lab, and had to implement the checks for current employees, some of whom were employed for many years.
The questions included standard background information, but then asked about drug use, sales, etc., and asked for explanations if the employee admitted to involvement with illegal drugs. After the employee answered the questions, the agency sent out questionnaires to landlords and references on a standard form. That standard form contains a number of questions to which plaintiffs objected:
the form asks if the reference has "any reason to question" the employee’s "honesty or trustworthiness." Id., at 97. It also asks if the reference knows of any "adverse information" concerning the employ. If "yes" is checked for any of these categories, the form calls for an explanation in the space below. ... That space is also available for providing "additional information" ("derogatory" or "favorable") that may bear on "suitability for government employment or a security clearance." Ibid.The Ninth Circuit held that the request for an explanation by the employee about drug treatment or counseling did not serve a legitimate interest sufficient to overcome the employee's privacy rights. The court of appeals also decided that the reference forms contained open ended questions that infringed on privacy rights without sufficient linkage to the job.
On review, the Supreme Court decided that these questions do not infringe upon privacy rights even if they were protected by the Constitution:
The questions challenged by respondents are part of a standard employment background check of thesort used by millions of private employers. See Brief for Consumer Data Indus. Assn. et al. asThe court's decision is important to private sector employers looking to justify personal questions and investigative consumer reports. The court recognized the legitimacy of these issues, including questions about drug use. That should help private-sector and public employers with invasion of privacy claims related to drug testing and background investigations.
*** [W]e conclude that the chal-lenged portions of both SF–85 and Form 42 consist of reasonable, employment-related inquiries that further the Government’s interests in managing its internal opera-tions. See Engquist, 553 U. S., at 598–599; Whalen, 429 U. S., at 597–598. As to SF–85, the only part of the formchallenged here is its request for information about “any treatment or counseling received” for illegal-drug use within the previous year. The “treatment or counseling”question, however, must be considered in context. It is a followup to SF–85’s inquiry into whether the employee has“used, possessed, supplied, or manufactured illegal drugs” during the past year. The Government has good reason toask employees about their recent illegal-drug use. Like any employer, the Government is entitled to have itsprojects staffed by reliable, law-abiding persons who will“‘efficiently and effectively’” discharge their duties. See Engquist, supra, at 598–599. Questions about illegal-drug use are a useful way of figuring out which persons havethese characteristics.Amici Curiae 2 (hereinafter CDIA Brief) ("[M]ore than 88% of U. S.companies . . . perform background checks on their employees"). The Government itself has been conducting employment investigations since the earliest days of the Republic.
Of course the court did not deal with the issue of "adverse impact" discrimination claims here. But the defense to adverse impact is "job related and consistent with business necessity." Language in this opinion should help estasblish this defense.
The opinion is NASA v. Nelson and it is here.
DGV
Labels:
background check,
Privacy,
supreme court
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)